soundcore P31i Best Overall
Key details
- Noise Cancellation
- Adaptive ANC, up to 52 dB
- Battery
- 8 hrs with ANC; 40 hrs with case
- Water Resistance
- IP55
- Audio Codec
- LDAC, Hi-Res certified
Fifty-two decibels of adaptive cancellation is a number we expect on earbuds selling for several times this price, and the kind of claim that usually shrinks in a real room. The P31i was the set we were most prepared to be disappointed by, and instead it quieted a train carriage, an open-plan office, and a window air conditioner more convincingly than anything else in this group.
That's why it's our top pick, and LDAC is the second reason — the Android-specific one. LDAC is a high-bitrate codec your Pixel or Galaxy can send and an iPhone can't, so the hi-res certification earns its keep here in a way it wouldn't on the other side of the aisle: guitars and cymbals arrive with more texture than a plain AAC connection gives them. Battery is rated 10 hours per charge, 8 with cancellation running, and 50 hours with the case, which covers a week of commuting without hunting for a cable.
Four sizes of ear tip ship in the box, XS through L, and that's the detail we care about more than the decibel figure. The seal is what lets cancellation and bass happen at all, and most sets stop at small; starting at extra-small gives narrow canals a fighting chance. The app handles noise-canceling levels and firmware, and there's a transparency mode for the moment someone talks to you.
The one thing to watch is pairing. Some units need a second attempt before they settle down, so get them connected at home on Wi-Fi rather than on a platform with a train due.
Pros
- Best-supported noise canceling in this group
- LDAC hi-res audio that Android supports
- 8 hours per charge with ANC, 40 with case
- Four ear-tip sizes for a reliable seal
Cons
- Pairing takes a second try on some phones
Our top pick for Android: it's the set whose noise canceling holds up best here, and LDAC makes the hi-res claim real on a Pixel or a Galaxy.